Color Commentary at the U.S. Supreme Court
The whistle blows -- Chief Justice Roberts takes center court, bouncing the gavel and tossing up the ceremonial opening question. Right away, Justice Kagan intercepts the momentum -- sharp, analytical, cutting straight through the textual defense. She's driving down the lane, threading hypotheticals like no-look passes. Justice Alito's stepping in -- oh -- a strong block on that line of reasoning, insisting the plain meaning of the statute can't just travel . That's vintage Alito: firm stance in the paint, citing legislative intent from way downtown. Justice Jackson's moving fast on the periphery, setting up a zone defense around the concept of "fairness." She's probing, probing -- asking, "Counsel, where's the limiting principle?" That's a deep cut question -- forces the advocate to pivot and rethink their entire playbook. Here comes Justice Sotomayor -- she's got empathy on th...